NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY (2018-2020)
The results of CBS research conducted by the team at Newcastle University – led by Professor John-Paul Taylor, Dr Kat da Silva Morgan in conjunction with Professor Dominic ffytche at King’s College London – will be peer reviewed and published in 2021.
There were two parts to this research.
Part One investigated the difference in the brains between patients with sight loss and CBS against those with sight loss but who did not develop the condition.
Funded by Fight for Sight, Thomas Pocklington Trust and National Eye Research Centre
Part Two explored the possibility of using Transcranial direct current stimulation to target specific areas of the brain in order to modulate its activity. Early results have been very encouraging, with some patients reporting paler and smaller visual hallucinations.
Funded by The Macular Society
MOORFIELDS/UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON
Following the exacerbation of patients’ episodes of CBS during COVID-19’s induced lockdown, Professor Mariya Moosajee led an investigation ‘Understanding and mitigating the impact of social isolation on Charles Bonnet Syndrome amongst the sight impaired’.
Published in BMJ Open Ophthalmology in 2021 – https://bmjophth.bmj.com/content/6/1/e000670
Funded by the Wellcome Trust
MOORFIELDS/OXFORD EYE HOSPITAL
Led by Professor Moosajee (Moorfields) and Professor Susie Downes (Oxford), this will be a mini-CBS prevalence study across different specialities.
UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD
A research team from the Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences at the University of Oxford – led by Professor Holly Bridge and Dr Jasleen Jolly – will use MRI scans to compare the brains of people with and without Charles Bonnet syndrome to look at how they differ.
Professor Holly Bridge said: “In the healthy visual system the eye provides input to a large area of the brain that allow us to see the world. There are specialised brain regions responsible for the processing of faces, objects, motion and colour. When the eye is no longer working these parts of the brain lose their input and we think this can lead to abnormal activity. In particular we will use a special type of MRI scan in this study to measure the levels of chemicals in the visual areas of the brain to see whether they are abnormal in CBS, leading to the hallucinations.”
Not all people with eye disease and vision loss develop CBS, so we will use magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to compare the brains of people with and without the condition. In particular we are interested in measuring the levels of chemicals in the visual areas of the brain to see whether they are disrupted in CBS, leading to the hallucinations. We can also measure how the different areas of the visual brain are connected together and see whether this is altered in CBS, perhaps with increases in the strength of connection between specialised areas.
The study will provide insight into the role of the brain in generating CBS hallucinations, helping us to design a larger study and eventually to test whether there are interventions to help improve the condition.
The research is funded by Esme’s Umbrella, Blind Veterans, NIHR, The Royal Society, The College of Optometrists
Researchers at Cardiff University are embarking on a new study to investigate whether peripheral (side) vision is more ‘suggestible’ than central vision.
The team – led by Dr Matt J. Dunn from the School of Optometry and Vision Sciences – will use a novel technique to induce controlled visual hallucinations in the lab. They are particularly interested in whether these lab-induced hallucinations more readily occur when targeted to the visual periphery (side vision) than straight-ahead. The team hope to gain a better understanding of how the brain interprets visual signals from different parts of the retina, which may help to explain the origins of Charles Bonnet Syndrome.
Dr Dunn said: “Although many people with Charles Bonnet Syndrome report hallucinations that appear to be located in the central visual field, we know that central vision is almost always damaged in these patients, so we are interested in where those signals might originate from. We hope to gain a better understanding of the role of expectation on visual perception in fully-sighted individuals, in order to provide a plausible explanation as to why Charles Bonnet Syndrome and other hallucinatory disorders occur in the first place”.
In this study we are testing a hypothesis that following long-term central vision loss, patients with Charles Bonnet Syndrome pay more attention to their peripheral vision, which is more reliant on expectation and previous experience than central vision, and therefore prone to hallucinatory experiences. We will use a novel lab-based test to measure a person’s reliance on prior expectation when generating visual percepts. This test will be applied to fully-sighted people using visual stimuli shown to both central and peripheral visual locations. Our aim is to determine whether peripheral vision is more suggestable than central vision.”
The research is co-funded by Fight for Sight and Health and Care Research Wales.
MOORFIELDS/UCL AND GREAT ORMOND STREET HOSPITALS
Led by Professor Mariya Moosajee and Dr Lee Jones, the team will conduct a prevalence study of paediatric ophthalmology clinics to ascertain how common CBS in children. The study will then look at how CBS affects the lives of the children and the family.
Part one – https://bjo.bmj.com/content/early/2020/09/15/bjophthalmol-2020-317237 published 16th September 2020.
Funded by Thomas Pocklington Trust
MEDICAL DETECTION DOGS
Following the revelation that, at least one, guide dog is warning her owner before a CBS episode begins, The Medical Detection Dogs will investigate what change in the odour of the human body is being detected by the dog. This may lead to more research into the chemicals of the brain.
Funded by Medical Detection Dogs
Katharine Fisher, a PhD student at the University of Manchester’s School of Health Studies, will be conducting an exploration of how we can prevent people with CBS from falling. This is a very common occurrence because, even if the person is well aware that the hallucination is not real, the nature of the image will, inevitably, induce a physical reaction – and over-balancing or falling over an item of furniture is the result.
This may entail a trip to hospital or the GP, with a decision to make – to confide or not to confide. Confiding to a doctor – who probably has no idea about CBS – about the tiger/snake/person which caused the fall might result in a mis-diagnosis and a trip down the mental health route.
Katherine’s PhD fees are funded by Thomas Pocklington Trust
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN
The first CBS prevalence study will be conducted by Fighting Blindness and University College Dublin in the autumn of 2020/beginning of 2021 – which will lead to a wider piece of research.